Is It a Crime to Encourage Unauthorized Immigration? The Supreme Court Will Decide
WASHINGTON — A 1986 federal law makes it a crime to “encourage” unauthorized immigrants to come to or stay in the United States.
“The statute potentially criminalizes the simple words — spoken to a son, a wife, a parent, a friend, a neighbor, a co-worker, a student, a client — ‘I encourage you to stay here,’” Judge A. Wallace Tashima wrote last year for a unanimous panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, in striking down the law.
The law applies to a grandmother urging a grandchild to overstay a visa or a lawyer advising a client to stay in the country while fighting deportation, Judge Tashima wrote. It may cover public officials helping immigrants in sanctuary cities and perhaps even speeches at immigration rallies, he wrote.
Last month, the Supreme Court agreed to decide whether the law can be squared with the First Amendment. The case, United States v. Sineneng-Smith, No. 19-67, is one of several significant immigration matters on the court’s docket. On Tuesday, the court will hear arguments on whether the Trump administration can rescind protections for so-called Dreamers. Later in the term, it will consider whether immigrants can go to court to challenge orders calling for their expedited removal.
The First Amendment case concerns Evelyn Sineneng-Smith, who ran an immigration consulting firm in San Jose, Calif. Her clients, mostly from the Philippines, worked without authorization in the home health care industry. Ms. Sineneng-Smith offered to help them get green cards under a Labor Department certification program that she said would give them permanent resident status and allow them to work legally.
But the program had expired. Ms. Sineneng-Smith nonetheless charged her clients $6,800 to file applications she knew to be futile. She was convicted of mail fraud, a conviction that the Ninth Circuit affirmed and that Ms. Sineneng-Smith is not challenging in the Supreme Court. The question for the justices is whether her separate conviction under the 1986 law for encouraging her clients to stay in the United States was proper.
In the Ninth Circuit, Ms. Sineneng-Smith argued that she had a First Amendment right to file the applications, which was not a particularly strong argument. “Speech integral to criminal conduct,” the Supreme Court has said, is not protected by the First Amendment.
When the case reached the Ninth Circuit, it did something unusual. It asked for briefing on a different First Amendment question. The court wanted to know whether the law was overbroad, chilling the free speech of people other than Ms. Sineneng-Smith.
After getting additional briefs and hearing another round of arguments, the appeals court ruled that the law was unconstitutional.
In urging the Supreme Court to hear its appeal, the Trump administration said the Ninth Circuit had gone too far. The Supreme Court has said that striking down laws because they are too broad is “strong medicine” to be used only when the laws are unconstitutional in a substantial number of real-world settings rather than in “fanciful hypotheticals.”
In his Ninth Circuit opinion, Judge Tashima said that his examples of possible prosecutions “are not some parade of fanciful horribles.”
“Instead,” he wrote, “they represent real and constitutionally protected conversations and advice that happen daily.”
Whatever the literal language of the 1986 law, Solicitor General Noel J. Francisco wrote for the government in its petition seeking review, criminal laws are “ordinarily understood not to prohibit abstract advocacy of illegality.”
“Just as a teenager does not aid, abet or solicit marijuana possession merely by saying to a friend, ‘I encourage you to try smoking pot,’” Mr. Francisco wrote, a grandmother does not violate the 1986 law “merely by saying to her grandson whose visa has expired, ‘I encourage you to stay.’”
Mr. Francisco asked the justices to decide only whether speech made for financial gain could be made criminal. The 1986 law does discuss financial gain, but in a separate provision allowing longer sentences when money is involved.
Prosecutions under the law tend to be limited to cases concerning classically criminal conduct by unsympathetic defendants. But not always. In 2012, for instance, a Massachusetts woman, Lorraine Henderson, was convicted of hiring an unauthorized immigrant to clean her home and offering general and not always reliable advice about immigration law.
In that case, Judge Douglas P. Woodlock, of the Federal District Court in Boston, wrote that the “plain and unadorned language” of the law “can be read to cast a wide net over those who interact with illegal aliens by offering employment.”
Judge Woodlock did not consider First Amendment issues in his decision, but he granted Ms. Henderson’s motion for a new trial based on his misgivings about the sweep of the law. Prosecutors dropped the case.
In Ms. Sineneng-Smith’s case, the government argued that it did not pursue prosecutions based on ordinary interactions with unauthorized immigrants.
That was small comfort, Judge Tashima wrote. “Just because the government has not (yet) sought many prosecutions based on speech,” he wrote, “it does not follow that the government cannot or will not use an overbroad law to obtain such convictions.”
In the Supreme Court, Ms. Sineneng-Smith’s lawyers said they should be allowed to challenge the law in order to protect the constitutional rights of other people.
“The very reason that overbroad laws are subject to facial attack,” they wrote, “is to remedy the chilling effect resulting from keeping such laws on the books.”
Sanders’ immigration plan: Halt deportations, abolish ICE, welcome 50K ‘climate migrants,’ give welfare to all Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., on Thursday released a sweeping immigration plan that would impose a moratorium on deportations, “break up” existing immigration enforcement agencies, grant full … read more
Democrat Sanders vows to halt immigration raids, deportations if elected president By Simon Lewis WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. Democratic presidential contender Bernie Sanders said on Thursday he would put a moratorium on deportations from the United States and end raids … read more
Singer-songwriter Jessie Reyez says the immigration crisis along the southern U.S. border inspired her recent music video, “Far Away.” She also discusses gearing up for her debut album. (Nov. 6) Subscribe for more Breaking News: http://smarturl.it/AssociatedPress Website: https://apnews.com Twitter: https://twitter.com/AP … read more
France Announces Tough New Measures on Immigration PARIS — President Emmanuel Macron of France tried to seize control of the issue of immigration on Wednesday, as his government announced steps to make the country less attractive to migrants while cracking … read more
Curveballs in race for DHS secretary, as immigration hawks face barriers As outgoing Homeland Security Secretary Kevin McAleenan sticks around amid a still-unsettled search for a successor, the man border hawks hope will take a harder line on immigration in that … read more
Emails cast doubt on claim of immigration visit to school NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Emails cast fresh doubt on a recent claim that immigration officials visited a Nashville school asking for student records. In an Oct. 11 email among Nashville … read more
#Trump #TrumpImpeachment #Immigration #ABCNews SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: https://www.youtube.com/ABCNews/ Watch More on http://abcnews.go.com/ LIKE ABC News on FACEBOOK https://www.facebook.com/abcnews FOLLOW ABC News on TWITTER: Tweets by ABC GOOD MORNING AMERICA’S HOMEPAGE: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/ read more
California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers LOS ANGELES, Oct 11 (Reuters) – California moved to end the use of private, for-profit lockups in America’s largest state prison system as well as in federal immigration detention centers in the … read more
Judge blocks Trump immigration rule, calls it ‘repugnant to American Dream’ NEW YORK (Reuters) – A U.S. federal judge in New York on Friday temporarily blocked a Trump administration rule that would deny residency to aspiring immigrants deemed likely to … read more
#foreigninfluence #turkey #syria #immigration #montgomerymayor SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: https://www.youtube.com/ABCNews/ Watch More on http://abcnews.go.com/ LIKE ABC News on FACEBOOK https://www.facebook.com/abcnews FOLLOW ABC News on TWITTER: Tweets by ABC GOOD MORNING AMERICA’S HOMEPAGE: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/ read more
Woman who confronted Beto O’Rourke on immigration, guns speaks out on his reaction The Arizona woman who confronted 2020 presidential candidate Beto O’Rourke over illegal immigration and his push for the government to confiscate certain types of guns told Fox News he was “pandering … read more
Australia’s tough stance on immigration has helped keep down the vote for far-right political parties, the country’s ambassador to France has told Euronews.… READ MORE : https://www.euronews.com/2019/10/08/australia-s-tough-immigration-stance-keeps-far-right-at-bay Subscribe to our channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/euronews?sub_confirmation=1 Watch our LIVE here: https://www.youtube.com/c/euronews/live read more
French politicians are debating the country’s immigration system ahead of elections in 2020. … READ MORE : https://www.euronews.com/2019/10/08/france-debates-immigration-after-macron-says-country-shouldn-t-be-too-attractive-to-migran Subscribe to our channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/euronews?sub_confirmation=1 Watch our LIVE here: https://www.youtube.com/c/euronews/live read more
Suit says feds using immigration marriage interviews as trap Alyse and Elmer Sanchez were thrilled when they survived their “green card” interview, a crucial step in obtaining lawful status in the United States. She texted her family from the immigration … read more
McAleenan leaves immigration conference after interrupted by protesters – Fox News Acting Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kevin McAleenan was scheduled to deliver the keynote speech at Georgetown Law’s 16th Annual Immigration Law and Policy Conference. McAleenan left the stage … read more
Selena Gomez Speaks Out About Immigration: ‘I Feel Afraid for My Country’ – Showbiz Cheat Sheet Selena Gomez is using her celebrity status to make a difference — lending her voice and personal experience to the immigration crisis in a … read more
2nd Indian hunger-striker released from immigration custody A second Indian man who refused to eat for more than 70 days in U.S. immigration custody has been released after a year in detention. Gurjant Singh left a detention center in El … read more
House Judiciary Immigration & Citizenship Subcommittee and House Foreign Affairs Oversight & Investigations Subcommittee hold a joint hearing on “Oversight of the Trump Admin’s Muslim Ban.” #FoxNews FOX News operates the FOX News Channel (FNC), FOX Business Network (FBN), FOX … read more
Inside Trump’s immigration tent courts: Controversial system meant to fast-track asylum backlog LAREDO, Texas — The white tents that sit here on the very edge of the U.S border, with Mexico a literal stone’s throw away, represent one of the jewels … read more
Castro praised Obama immigration policies for years – before attacking Biden over them Julián Castro took former Vice President Joe Biden to task at last week’s Democratic presidential primary debate for trying to downplay his role in the Obama administration’s immigration … read more
Trump campaign aims to use immigration, trade to win Hispanic vote in 2020 ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. – President Trump’s campaign team thinks he has a shot at winning New Mexico with a message on immigration and trade. At a rally in … read more
Critics say linking immigration and “Protecting the European way of life” panders to the far-right.… READ MORE : https://www.euronews.com/2019/09/16/eu-commissioner-johannes-hahn-defends-controversial-european-way-of-life-portfolio Subscribe to our channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/euronews?sub_confirmation=1 Watch our LIVE here: https://www.youtube.com/c/euronews/live read more