M.I.T. Researchers Cast Doubt on Bolivian Election Fraud
BOGOTÁ, Colombia — Researchers from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology have cast doubt on a claim that Bolivian officials engaged in fraud to help Evo Morales, the longtime president, win re-election.
The researchers, while not definitively ruling out the possibility of any fraud, waded into a fierce domestic and international debate over Mr. Morales’s legitimacy. The country’s first Indigenous president, he was a historic but contentious figure, forced out in November after violent protests and accusations that his allies had rigged the election.
“The statistical evidence does not support the claim of fraud,” the researchers, John Curiel and Jack R. Williams, wrote in The Washington Post. Their work was commissioned by a group called the Center for Economic and Policy Research, which has been supportive of left-leaning governments in South America.
Mr. Curiel and Mr. Williams, from M.I.T.’s Election Data and Science Lab, said they were contracted to conduct an independent analysis.
Their assessment met with scathing criticism from the Organization of American States, which conducted an initial audit in late 2019 that found Bolivian officials had engaged in lies, manipulation and forgery to ensure Mr. Morales’s victory.
The O.A.S. said it stood by its findings.
“It defies all logic that individuals that hold themselves out as ‘scientists’ and ‘specialists in election integrity’ would engage in such flawed analysis,” wrote Gonzalo Koncke, an O.A.S. official, in a letter to The Post.
The researchers’ work did not address many of the allegations mentioned in the O.A.S. report, including the accusation that Bolivian officials maintained hidden servers that could have permitted the alteration of results.
Instead, the researchers examined one allegation made by O.A.S. auditors: that differences in results reported before and after a pause in the initial vote count pointed to evidence of fraud in favor of Mr. Morales.
O.A.S. officials called a sudden change in the voting trend in Mr. Morales’s favor “statistically unlikely.”
But the researchers concluded that such a change was entirely plausible. “There does not seem to be a statistically significant difference in the margin before and after the halt of the preliminary vote,” they wrote.
They pointed out that voting trends often shift as votes are counted. In the United States, for example, votes that come in after Election Day tend to favor Democratic candidates.
The fraud claims have been central to a debate about whether Mr. Morales should be able to return to political life in Bolivia — and whether his party, Movement Toward Socialism, should get another shot at national leadership.
In early May, Bolivians will vote again for a new president. Mr. Morales can’t run; he is in exile in Argentina and faces criminal charges at home. But his candidate, Luis Arce, is leading in the polls.
In an email, Mr. Curiel called for further analysis of the fraud claims, noting that the O.A.S. came to its conclusions “on a quick turnaround,” just days after the election.
Coronavirus clampdown spreads fear and doubt in northern Italy By Valentina Za and Francesca Landini MILAN, Feb 23 (Reuters) – Some people fled, some stocked up on essentials, others simply called for calm after authorities imposed stringent measures on swathes … read more
Timing of 9/11 Trial in Doubt After Defense Lawyer Asks to Quit Case This article was produced in partnership with the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting. GUANTÁNAMO BAY, Cuba — A long-serving capital defense lawyer for one of the five … read more
Chinese GP in doubt as Shanghai suspends all sporting events Chinese GP in doubt as Shanghai suspends all sporting events SHANGHAI (Reuters) – Shanghai sports authorities have recommended the suspension of all sporting events in the city due to the … read more
When game was in doubt, Mahomes didn’t flinch He was en route to his worst performance as a professional in his biggest game as a professional, down double digits in the face of a vicious San Francisco defense and a … read more
Research Casts Doubt on Cannabis as a Reliable Pain and Insomnia Treatment Millions of people worldwide have used medical cannabis to treat a wide range of health conditions, including post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, cancer, epilepsy, and irritable bowel syndrome. As … read more
A Trump ally cast doubt on whether House Republicans would be on the president’s defense team. A Trump ally cast doubt on whether House Republicans would be on the president’s defense team. Representative Matt Gaetz of Florida, a Republican and … read more
Trump administration casts doubt on women’s rights amendment push WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The Trump administration on Wednesday said it was too late to renew the effort to push through a decades-old proposed amendment to the U.S. Constitution that would ensure … read more
Ertz’s status in doubt as Eagles vie for NFC East The status of Philadelphia Eagles tight end Zach Ertz for their key season-finale remained in doubt Wednesday as he continues to be evaluated for a fractured rib. The team listed … read more
Trump Impeachment Trial in Doubt as a House Leader Suggests Withholding Articles WASHINGTON — The future of the House’s impeachment case against President Trump hung in doubt on Thursday, after the third-ranking House Democrat raised the possibility that the chamber … read more
Lawyer Casts Doubt on Boy’s Statements About Murder of Barnard Student – The New York Times A defense lawyer for a 13-year-old boy accused in the killing of a Barnard College student last week contended on Tuesday that detectives had … read more
Power Rankings: Reasons to doubt the Niners? There aren’t many San Francisco 49ers doubters left, but they were validated Sunday. The Atlanta Falcons were 4-9 before a date at San Francisco. The 49ers were one of two 11-2 teams in … read more
PG&E’s future is in doubt after Newsom rejects bankruptcy plan – Los Angeles Times Gov. Gavin Newsom on Friday rejected Pacific Gas & Electric’s proposal to pull itself out of bankruptcy, saying its reorganization plan falls “woefully short” of safety … read more
No Doubt: These 5 .45 Caliber Pistols Are The Best In The World Kyle Mizokami Security, Which made the list? Key point: The .45 ACP has benefitted from increased performance. The .45 Automatic Colt Pistol round, or .45 ACP as … read more
Barr Is Said to Doubt Inspector General’s Finding on Russia Inquiry WASHINGTON — Attorney General William P. Barr has told Justice Department officials that he is skeptical of a conclusion by the department’s inspector general that the F.B.I. had sufficient … read more
Murray a doubt for Britain’s clash with Spain By Martyn Herman MADRID (Reuters) – British Davis Cup captain said Andy Murray may be left out of Saturday’s Davis Cup semi-final against Spain as the former world number one is not … read more
Wall Street continues to doubt that AT&T’s new streaming service, dubbed HBO Max, will be a success without the help of “Game of Thrones” — even as it plans to launch a prequel of the wildly popular show. Shares of … read more
Impeachment witnesses cast doubt on Trump’s motives for requesting Ukrainian investigations WASHINGTON — At the heart of the impeachment drama gripping the nation’s capital is the question of whether President Trump’s attempts to solicit Ukrainian investigations of former Vice President Joe … read more
Innocent on Death Row? New Evidence Casts Doubt on Convictions The number of executions in the United States remains close to nearly a three-decade low. And yet the decline has not prevented what those who closely track the death penalty … read more
Ron Johnson casts doubt on Vindman testimony, says NSC official fits ‘profile’ of Never-Trumper Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis., sent a letter on Monday to the ranking Republicans on the House Intelligence and Oversight Committees in which he detailed his account … read more
Big study casts doubt on need for many heart procedures – PBS NewsHour PHILADELPHIA — People with severe but stable heart disease from clogged arteries may have less chest pain if they get a procedure to improve blood flow rather … read more
LeBron: ‘Everyone had doubt’ whether anyone would sign Carmelo Click to expand Replay Video UP NEXT Highlights: Browns top Steelers in game marred by brawl Watch Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Cleveland Browns highlights from Week 11 of the 2019 season. NFL … read more