It’s Difficult To Do Worse Than These 5 Aircraft Carriers
Not very well designed.
Key Point: Aircraft carriers are complex vessels.
Aircraft carriers are, with the possible exception of submarines, the most complicated naval vessels afloat. Not only do carriers have the traditional concerns of warships to deal with, they must also safely manage a fleet of aircraft which are often complicated in their own right. Despite these complications, carriers are among the most useful and lethal of warships. Even now, 100 years after the first purpose-built carrier HMS Hermes was laid down, major naval powers are still building these ships.
Not everyone does aircraft carriers correctly, and there have been several clunkers with the CV designation. Most of these ships are from the early years of naval aviation, before roles and missions were clearly assigned and the technology to build them was in its adolescent years. Others were poorly designed by latecomers to the aircraft carrier game, and some were perfectly useful ships made bad by insufficient training, maintenance or aircraft.
Hyuga and Ise:
During the First World War, Japan launched two new battleships of the Ise-class. Ise and her sister ship Hyuga were 640 feet long and displaced 29,990 tons. The two ships were each armed with twelve 14-inch guns mounted in six turrets of two guns each, twenty 5.5-inch guns and four 3-inch guns. The battleships each had twelve inches of steel armor at the main belt, tapering to three inches at the ends, deck armor of up to 2.5 inches, and eight inches of armor protecting the main guns.
The Battle of Midway proved a disaster for Imperial Japan, with the loss of four top of the line aircraft carriers to determined American aerial attacks. The decision was made to convert the two battleships into battleship carriers. Both Japan and the United States had converted large warships into aircraft carriers, but this had typically occurred during the construction process, far before the ships were complete.
How the Battle of the Philippine Sea Shattered Imperial Japan’s Carriers for Good Warfare History Network History, Asia A decisive victory. Key point: Without carriers, Tokyo could not project power or properly defend its homeland. The other invasion also began on … read more
Could Japan Turn Its Helicopter Assault Ships Into Carriers for the F-35? David Axe Technology, Americas Power projection returns to Tokyo. Key point: It will take a lot of modifications to transform Tokyo’s two helicopter carriers. The British company that built … read more
America’s New Aircraft Carriers Are Vulnerable To Russia And China Robert Farley Security, But “obsolete” ships can still be useful. Key Point: Aircraft carriers’ main job is not to penetrate A2/AD systems, and “obsolete” ships are still useful for decades. … read more
How China’s Submarines Became a Major Threat to U.S. Aircraft Carriers David Axe Security, Americas Years in the making. Key point: Beijing invested in its submarines over the last few decades to ensure it could hold American carriers at risk. … read more
RIP, Aircraft Carriers and Submarines: How Much of the U.S. Navy is Obsolete? Harry J. Kazianis Security, Are America’s submarines and aircraft carriers out of place? Key Point: The Pentagon is already refocusing itself on how to deploy power projection in … read more
Why The Navy Should Have Never Built So Many Aircraft Carriers David W. Wise Security, A tool of a past age. Key point: Their survivability has been taken for granted. “History,” it has been written, “does not repeat itself, but … read more
Back in 2005, the U.S. Navy Tried To Sink One Of Its Very Own Aircraft Carriers David Axe Security, Easier said than done. Key point: And they call these warships obsolete? A Chinese admiral and pundit told a trade-show audience … read more
China Cancelled Two Super Aircraft Carriers. Here’s the Story Why. Sebastien Roblin Security, Asia For over a decade, China has been steadily building up plans to deploy six aircraft carriers of progressively greater capability. Key point: In a high-intensity conflict with … read more
We Now Know Why Imperial Japan Didn’t Keep Building Aircraft Carriers To Fight America Warfare History Network History, Asia Its industrial capacity was shot. Key Point: Was this a big mistake or did Tokyo have no choice? Japan lacked the … read more
20 Deadliest Pieces of Military Hardware on the Planet (Think Aircraft Carriers and Stealth) Robert Farley Security, Americas No military can stop them–or at least they will pay a heavy price for trying. In today’s world, where everyday it seems … read more
RIP: The One Thing That Could Send All Aircraft Carriers to the Scraper Robert Farley Security, Americas Hypersonic missiles? Key Point: Could hypersonic missiles do the job? We know how to kill aircraft carriers—or at least we know how best … read more
British Aircraft Carriers Could Soon Be Sailing In The U.S. Navy Michael Peck Security, Britain needs cash. Key point: The Royal Navy is pushing hard to integrate its carriers with their U.S. counterparts. To offset a shrinking defense budget, the British … read more
These 5 Aircraft Carriers Aren’t Worth The Steel It Took To Build Them Kyle Mizokami Security, Not every vessel can be great. Key Point: Kuznetsov is old and needs to be retired, but as Russia’s only carrier that likely won’t happen … read more
Game Over: The F-35 Will Be Ready to Attack From Aircraft Carriers Kris Osborn Security, North Korea better watch its back. Key Point: A carrier-launched stealth fighter would be a game-changer. The Navy’s stealthy carrier-launched F-35C is now moving much … read more
Russia and China Could Destroy America’s New Aircraft Carriers. Are They Obsolete Already? Robert Farley Security, The answer may surprise you… Key Point: Aircraft carriers’ main job is not to penetrate A2/AD systems, and “obsolete” ships are still useful for … read more
India Has Aircraft Carriers, But Are They Worth Anything? Robert Beckhusen Security, Pakistan is ready to sink whatever India throws at it. Key Point: When compared with Pakistani costal defenses, it’s easy to conclude that India’s aircraft carriers don’t bring much … read more
Iran Has A Lot Of Missiles, And Is Ready To Use Them Against America’s Aircraft Carriers Kyle Mizokami Security, Middle East A real threat. Key Point: Even under ideal circumstances, Iran’s missile arsenal is unlikely to pose a credible threat against … read more
The U.S. Navy And China Want To Kill Each Other’s Aircraft Carriers James Holmes Security, Chinese missiles vs. American strike groups. Key point: China is focusing on its near-abroad, while the Navy is better prepared for conflict on the open seas. … read more
The Russian Navy Has a Big Decision to Make: Time to Give up on Aircraft Carriers? James Holmes Security, What will Moscow do now that its carrier just had another major setback? Fire aboard ship is never funny. Not to … read more
Meet the 5 Best Battleships and Aircraft Carriers in History TNI Staff History, World War! What is it good for? Really big ships! Key point: Comparing ships is like comparing apples and oranges, but there are some standards. For decades, … read more
BOOM: U.S. Navy Modifies Its Aircraft Carriers for F-35C Stealth Attack Warrior Maven Security, Americas The future of warfare is here. (Washington, D.C.) The Navy is preparing its first two new Ford-class aircraft carriers to launch air attacks with the … read more
Russia Could Kill American Carriers Without the “Poseidon” Nuclear Torpedo Michael Peck Technology, Europe Overkill? Key point: Moscow likes scary weapons, even though they might not be practically usable. Russia has begun underwater tests of its Poseidon thermonuclear torpedo. The Poseidon … read more
Just a Bunch of Rust: Why Russia’s Kiev-Class Aircraft Carriers Failed Kyle Mizokami History, Europe Where did they end up? Key point: Four of these fixed-wing carriers were built. At the tail end of the Cold War, the Soviet Union produced … read more
Meet Imperial Japan’s Strange ‘Underwater’ Aircraft Carriers Warfare History Network Security, Asia A predecessor to the modern ballistic submarine. Key Point: One of Japan’s most farsighted technological advancements went on to become a foundational part of U.S. military strength. Lieutenant Commander … read more