Lord of the Rings Debate: How the Battle of Helms Deep Was Won
The Angry Staff Officer
The forces of Rohan were able to mount a successful defensive operation at the Hornburg through mutually supporting positions, clearly defined fallback criteria, and sound leadership using mission command.
As an engineer officer, I care passionately about just a few things: castles, engineer buttons, and combined arms breaching. And while there were no engineer buttons at Helm’s Deep – a simple oversight, I’m sure – that engagement encompasses a wide swathe of engineer lessons learned.
Yes, this means we’re delving back into the world of J.R.R. Tolkien, to keep him from getting any well-earned rest by pestering him for military insights from his work of fiction, The Two Towers. Specifically, from the engagement between the coalition forces of Rohan and the hybrid threat of Saruman’s army.
And for those of us who care about such things, this is not the actual battle of Helm’s Deep, because that place referred to the ravine behind the fortress. Properly, it is called the Battle of the Hornburg. But since people can’t read maps properly and then some of those people make movies, it has become known as the Battle of Helm’s Deep. And you wonder why historians drink.
This engagement is quite different from that at Minas Tirith which was handled in a previous post. While that was a multi-domain operation with a wide array of forces, this engagement is in essence a light infantry – or even cavalry – defense of key terrain, opposing the most rudimentary of combined arms breaches. That was NTC, this is JRTC. The problem statement becomes, can a light cavalry force fight as heavy infantry inside obstacle belts and still preserve enough combat power to retain the initiative once the enemy attack has culminated?
It all boils down to overmatch and trading space for time, which are two pieces of the modern battlefield that might be very familiar for some readers, especially the ones wearing the obnoxious hats and spurs.
Lord of the Rings Debate: How the Battle of Helms Deep Was Won The Angry Staff Officer Security, World The forces of Rohan were able to mount a successful defensive operation at the Hornburg through mutually supporting positions, clearly defined … read more
Don’t Get Mad, but ‘Hangry’ Isn’t Really Angry ImageCredit…Bianca Bagnarelli The morning walk before a holiday meal can feel like an act of advance penance: a show of restraint before the feast, best performed under a pale sun, amid a … read more
‘We’re Just So Angry’: Australians Protest Police Killing of Aboriginal Teenager SYDNEY, Australia — Thousands of Australians have taken to the streets this week to protest the police killing of an Aboriginal teenager in a remote community, a case that … read more
From Instagram to Angry Birds, here are the top apps of the decade – CNET Angela Lang/CNET In the last decade, apps (and by association, smartphones) have become an essential part of our lives. Since the iOS App Store and … read more
‘I am angry and I own it’: Elizabeth Warren ignores Biden, implies sexism in fundraising note – The Boston Globe Advertisement The accusation reflects how some Warren supporters feel amid a onslaught from Biden and Buttigieg — sparked by a … read more
Antonio Brown is right to be angry at the NFL Brown and his camp are not alone in that assessment. Indeed, two lawyers who have waged significant battles with the NFL pertaining to the league’s investigative system and the collective-bargaining … read more
Trump touts his ‘angry majority’ ahead of elections **Want FOX News Halftime Report in your inbox every day? Sign up here.** On the roster: Trump touts his ‘angry majority’ ahead of elections – Poll: Biden widens lead over Trump, now 17 points – … read more
Rumer Willis Reveals Why She Was ‘Angry’ With Ashton Kutcher During Marriage To Demi Moore Rumer Willis appeared on ‘Red Table Talk’ with her mom Demi Moore and sister Tallulah Willis and discussed her mom’s marriage to the much younger … read more
Democrat or Republican, Americans are Angry, Frustrated and Overwhelmed María Celeste Wagner, Pablo J. Boczkowski Politics, Americas More Americans say they now avoid the news altogether. As the country looks ahead to President Donald Trump’s possible impeachment proceedings, as social … read more
UPDATE 1-Trump says "angry majority" supports him against impeachment drive (Adds poll on impeachment, quote on Jim Hood) By Steve Holland TUPELO, Miss., Nov 1 (Reuters) – President Donald Trump said on Friday he believed an “angry majority” of American … read more
Trump says "angry majority" supports him against impeachment drive By Steve Holland TUPELO, Miss., Nov 1 (Reuters) – President Donald Trump said on Friday he believed an “angry majority” of American voters will support him against an impeachment inquiry as … read more
Young, angry Lebanese ditch their differences to target "unjust" system By Suleiman Al-Khalidi and Eric Knecht BEIRUT, Oct 23 (Reuters) – Like most young protesters flooding Lebanon’s streets to vent their fury over joblessness and inequality, Nina Sabbah demands more … read more
Activists angry police who shoot can wait to face questions FILE – In this Sept. 10, 2018, file photo, a Dallas Police vehicle is parked near the South Side Flats apartments in Dallas. Former Dallas Police Officer Amber Guyger fatally … read more
At Minneapolis Rally, an Angry Trump Reserves Sharpest Attack for Biden MINNEAPOLIS — A fired-up President Trump lashed out against Democrats at a combative campaign rally on Thursday night, deriding them as “very sick and deranged people” who were only … read more
In Attacking Rivals, an Angry Trump Reserves Sharpest for Biden MINNEAPOLIS — A fired-up President Trump lashed out against Democrats at a combative campaign rally on Thursday night, deriding them as “very sick and deranged people” who were investigating his … read more
The viral ‘Joker’ outtake with an angry Joaquin Phoenix originated as a prank on the movie’s director – Business Insider Server: Varnish Retry-After: 0 Content-Length: 0 Location: http://www.businessinsider.de/jimmy-kimmel-joaquin-phoenix-joker-outtake-was-prank-on-director-2019-10?r=US&IR=T Accept-Ranges: bytes Date: Mon, 07 Oct 2019 22:48:04 GMT Via: 1.1 varnish … read more
Very angry Jason Garrett throws challenge flag so hard that ref penalizes him Jason Garrett is fed up, everybody. During the play, it looked like Cooper hauled in the ball with his left foot inbounds while dragging his right toe. It was … read more
Trump seethes, angry tweets on the way to golf course after whirlwind impeachment week – Chicago Tribune Chicago Tribune – We are currently unavailable in your region Unfortunately, our website is currently unavailable in most European countries. We are engaged … read more
The ‘Snowpiercer’ TV Show Got A Rousing, Angry Sneak-Peek At New York Comic Con It’s been six long years since the world received Snowpiercer, Bong Joon-ho’s bold and angry (yet fun!) dystopian thriller about a class war breaking out on … read more
Angry Dutch farmers clog up 700 miles of highway during protest over emission rules Slow-moving convoys of tractors clogged up nearly 700 miles of major highways in the Netherlands on Tuesday, as farmers inched toward The Hague to protest what they claim is … read more
Angry De Niro Says ‘F-ck ’em’ to Fox News and Trump on Sunday News Show Robert De Niro couldn’t care less if Fox News doesn’t like his outspoken critiques of President Donald Trump. Responding to a prompt from CNN’s Brian … read more
Spaniards were frustrated and angry on Wednesday after being called to the polls for a fourth time in four years and some said they would stay away from the ballot box, making it harder to predict how the political deadlock … read more
Angry seal ‘helps’ Australian police bust drug smuggling ring An international drug smuggling ring was busted in Australia — with the help of an angry seal. The seal prevented the getaway of two foreign nationals from a small island off the … read more